2012  
Tarik Amon Belmont Abbey
2013  
Jahlan Gordo Delaware
2014  
John Oputa UMBC
Jamar Nash North Carolina A&T
Kardell Williams Navy
2015  
Kenneth Chigbue Howard
Joe Graham Mount St. Mary’s
Justin Hamilton North Carolina A&T
Darryl Haraway Florida State
Deon Haraway Hampton
Drew Talley Morehouse